Liquid chalk and regular dry chalk give you the grip you need when things start to get slippery. For decades, gymnasts have used chalk in various forms to prevent sweaty hands from affecting their performance. Both liquid chalk and dry chalk do the same thing. It adds a moisture-absorbing layer that enhances your skin’s traction. The differences are mostly in convenience and packaging, but liquid chalk does have an extra trick up its sleeve. Time to find out about the best liquid chalk and settle the debate between liquid chalk and Dry chalk.
You can also watch my Best Liquid Chalk Review on YouTube:
🔑Key Takeaways
- Dry chalk is messier, crumbles easily and is harder to transport than Liquid chalk.
- Liquid chalk is easier and safer to take with you and easier to apply, with less mess and no dust clouds.
- All major Calisthenics brands produce chalk, and there is no noticeable quality difference between these products.
Dry Chalk
Dry chalk is the traditional form of chalk. If you’ve ever used it, you know that it gets very messy. Any gym stand where people have been working with dry chalk will be awash with chalk powder. The stuff gets absolutely everywhere, including the floor, your clothes and even in your hair. Even with careful application, you’ll still make a mess. The chalk powder is so fine and light that even the lightest agitation sends clouds of the stuff to settle on whatever happens to be nearest.
This isn’t a problem in a traditional gym (for gymnastics). At home, though, it is very inconvenient to have this fine dust settle absolutely everywhere. Many modern gyms (for Calisthenics and Streetlifting) don’t allow the use of dry chalk because, frequently, people leave a chalk-smeared environment behind for the next guest. It is also hard to leave someone else’s equipment behind spotless if you’re just there in your gym outfit and a towel.
The main advantage of dry chalk is that you get more of the stuff for a smaller price than you get in a liquid chalk bottle.
Here is an overview of the dry chalk we tried:
10% off with our code: CWW10
| Brand | Regular Price | CWW10 Discount Price (est) |
| GORNATION | €16,90 | €15,21 |
| BARRIORZ | €16,45 | €14,81 |
| BarmaniaPRO | €15,90 | €14,31 |
Chalk Balls
Chalk balls are little sachets filled with powdered chalk. The powder is fine enough to find its way through the weave of the sachet. Just dabbing or lightly rubbing the ball on your hands or wrists is enough to release some powder onto that spot. It is a quick way to apply chalk, but also a messy one. The chalk is loose powder, and even the lightest dab sends millions of particles into the air.
A partial solution is to store the chalk ball itself in a sealable bag. That at least keeps the powder contained in the bag when not in use or when you’re transporting it.
Of all methods, this one is as fast to apply as the liquid kind and as easy to transport (in a sealable bag), but probably also the messiest for the surroundings.
Chalk Blocks
The most common form of dry chalk is in blocks. Here, the powder is compressed into a solid block that rubs off powder when you rub it. It is far less messy than a chalk ball, as particles are only released at the point of contact. I find this quite useful for quickly applying chalk to a small area where I need extra. This is theoretically more efficient than liquid chalk, since even the smallest dab in liquid form is too much to touch up a wrist or thumb.
Chalk blocks are not solid but just compressed loose powder. Eventually, all chalk blocks we know of tend to chip into shards and chunks. These fall to the floor and burst into a million pieces. Fresh out of the bag, Chalk blocks are much cleaner than chalk balls, but eventually they become just as messy or even messier.
Typically, the blocks come in sealable bags. However, this does not protect them from breaking apart. One solution we see more often is to place the block in a Tupperware tray or another hard container. Just don’t shake it…, ever.
Chalk Chunks
Chunky chalk is the worst of both blocks and powder bags. The chalk comes in loose chunks that easily disintegrate when you press them between your hands. Most of the contents of the bag it comes it is already powder by the time you buy it. Even the full-sized chunks send clouds of powder flying everywhere when you try to apply chalk to your hands. In practice, they make just as much of a mess as chalk balls, while not staying in one place like a block.
I don’t see any situation where you would prefer this type of Dry chalk.
Liquid Chalk
Liquid chalk comes in bottles with applicator lids. The chalk powder is suspended in a liquid that is typically lightly adhesive. This means all the chalk you apply stays where you apply it, at least until the adhesive has evaporated. Even after a while, the dried-up chalk tends to stick better and release fewer particles than Dry chalk.
You shake the bottle to stir everything inside into a proper suspension, then apply a small dab of chalk to your hand and smear it out to cover everything. There is no dust cloud and no chunks to chip off and disintegrate. The only way to make a mess is to spill it, and even then, the liquid wipes clean much more easily than a cloud of settled dust.
There are no different forms of liquid chalk, so there is no need to go over them, either. Most big Calisthenics brands have their own chalk, and aside from a differently shaped bottle and label, the contents all act and behave the same way. From cleanliness to grip and washability, we found literally no difference between them.
If you’re looking for the best liquid chalk, go for the cheapest per volume, or just shop at your favourite brand where you get your other Calisthenics equipment.
Here is an overview of the best liquid chalk we tried:
10% off with our code: CWW10
| Brand | Regular Price | CWW10 Discount Price (est) |
| GORNATION | €14,90 | €13,41 |
| Pullup & Dip | €14,13 | €12,72 |
| Gravity Fitness | £9.95 | – |
| BARRIORZ | €14,45 | €13,- |
| Eric Flag | €13,90 | €12,51 |
| Caliathletics | €15,00 | €13,50 |
| RaMaSS Fitness | €14,95 | €13,46 |
| BarmaniaPRO | €18,90 | – |
Liquid Chalk vs Dry Chalk: Transportability
The bottle that Liquid chalk comes in is far easier to transport. You can just toss it in your bag and not think twice about boarding a car, train or aeroplane. Dry chalk is more circumstantial. The chalk balls can be easily transported in a sealed bag, but if the seal breaks, you’ll have a mess. The transport itself can also easily break apart a chalk block or finely powder your chalk chunks.
For transportability, liquid chalk is the easy winner.
Liquid Chalk vs Dry Chalk: Cleanliness
Liquid chalk contains all the chalk particles in a suspension that is slightly adhesive. There are no dust clouds when you apply it, and even after drying, it tends to stick in place much better than Dry chalk.
With all Dry chalk types, you will see the first dust settling somewhere other than on your hands with just the application. Even taking the Dry chalk out of its container will send dust particles into the air. The closest to the liquid kind in terms of cleanliness comes a fresh chalk block, but even that makes a huge mess by comparison.
For cleanliness, liquid chalk is again the easy winner.
Liquid Chalk vs Dry Chalk: Grip
In practice, we don’t notice any difference between the grip quality you get from applying any of the chalks. Both liquid and dry chalk give you a better grip. The base ingredient, the chalk, is the same in all these products, and that’s what is doing the heavy lifting.
Between the Calisthenics brands, we also found no noticeable difference in grip or even how long the chalk lasts. The only advantage that Liquid chalk has is that it is slightly adhesive. The chalk particles tend to stick to your skin and the surfaces you touch for longer. This means you have to reapply chalk less often, and cleaning up any surfaces you touched is easier.
For grip, Liquid chalk tends to stick a bit longer than dry chalk, but there is zero difference between different Liquid chalk brands.
Conclusions About Liquid Chalk vs Dry Chalk
Whether to use liquid or dry chalk is a matter of convenience. Dry chalk is way messier in all its forms, even if you apply it perfectly. Transport is also more of a hassle with dry chalk, where you can just toss the liquid bottle into your gym bag. Dry chalk is typically cheaper than liquid chalk; however, you use more of it and have to reapply it more often.
Maybe a thing or two could be said if you buy chalk in professional quantities (a traditional gym, for instance), but for us individual users, liquid is just better in every way.
We’ve used all the liquid chalk bottles of the major Calisthenics brands. Our verdict about them is that they all perform the exact same. They all give you a great grip, last as long as the others, and wash off as easily. The only reason to differentiate between them to find the best liquid chalk is by comparing prices for the volume you get.
Frequently Asked Questions about the best Liquid Chalk
Here are a few more questions about liquid chalk and the argument between liquid chalk vs dry chalk.
Liquid chalk vs dry chalk?
Both types of chalk use magnesium carbonate as the primary ingredient to enhance grip and prevent sweat from making your hands slippery. Liquid chalk suspends magnesium in an ethanolic solution with a mild adhesive. Once the ethanol has evaporated, the chalk layer adheres more firmly to your skin. The result is less mess and a longer-lasting chalk layer.
Why do gyms only allow liquid chalk?
Liquid chalk causes much less mess and prevents dust clouds from forming in the gym. Visitors often fail to properly clean the equipment and surrounding area when dry chalk is used. For the proprietor, it makes sense to only allow liquid chalk for these reasons.
Why do climbers only use dry chalk?
Most climbers prefer dry chalk over liquid chalk because they apply chalk very frequently. When used as frequently as in climbing, liquid chalk can dry out the skin much faster. Climbing often causes small cuts and abrasions on the hands that sting when they come into contact with ethanol in liquid chalk.
